Citing racial bias, US high court tosses black man's murder conviction

Dale Gerstenslager  AP FILE
Curtis Giovanni Flowers left listens to testimony in his third capital murder trial in Winona Miss. Feb. 6 2004

A black MS inmate faces a possible seventh trial after the U.S. Supreme Court ruled 7-2 Friday that a prosecutor had displayed racial bias in jury selection.

In it, he condemned white prosecutor Doug Evans for blocking dozens of black jurors at all of Flowers' trials. "We can not ignore that history".

Justices Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch dissented.

Justice Thomas - who is the court's only African-American justice - pointed out that the defence had also used peremptory strikes to remove potential white jurors.

He was sentenced to death for the murders of four people inside a furniture store in Winona, Mississippi, in 1996.

Kavanaugh said the unusual history of the case; the prosecutor's documented effort to keep black people off the juries; and, "dramatically disparate questioning of black and white prospective jurors" all pointed to discrimination.

But deciding whether a potential juror was struck is a fact-specific inquiry.

He added: "If the court's opinion today has a redeeming quality, it is this: The state is perfectly free to convict Curtis Flowers again". If concerns are raised by one facet, the court has said, opposing attorneys must present a sound non-discriminatory clarification for inserting a juror.

Flowers was arrested several months after the murders, when two witnesses said they saw him near the scene of the crime. "We hope that the State of MS will finally disavow Doug Evans' misconduct, decline to pursue yet another trial, and set Mr. Flowers free".

More news: US Senate to block Trump's $8bn Saudi arms sale
More news: Cyclone Vayu around 1100 kms from Oman coast
More news: Cyclone 'Vayu' intensifies into severe cyclonic storm

This Aug. 3, 2017 listing supplied by Mississippi Division of Corrections reveals Curtis Vegetation, who's homicide case has long gone to trial six times.

Flowers has been in custody since 1996. Three of those trials ended in convictions that were reversed on appeal while one resulted in a mistrial. While the court sided with Flowers, its ruling does not preclude MS from putting him on trial for a seventh time.

Store owner Bertha Tardy, 59, deliveryman Robert Golden, 42, part-time employee Derrick Stewart, 16, and bookkeeper Carmen Rigby, 45, were shot and killed at the Tardy Furniture Store.

Kavanaugh said the Supreme Court wasn't breaking new ground in the case.

In the course of selecting a jury, lawyers can excuse a juror merely because of a suspicion that a particular person would vote against their client.

Batson provides that peremptory strikes - which allow lawyers to boot prospective jurors for any reason at all - can not be used to exclude people based on race.

While prosecutors and defense lawyers are allowed to use what are called peremptory challenges to eliminate potential jurors they are not allowed to do so on the basis of race.

Vegetation had worked on the retailer, however had lately been fired. A week earlier, Kavanaugh sided with liberals in a 5-4 decision that he wrote, ruling that Apple could be sued by iPhone owners over high prices in their App Store. District Attorney Doug Evans struck five other African-Americans from the jury pool in the process. "The State tried to strike all 36".

In the sixth trial prosecutors disallowed five of six black jurors, which Vegetation argued became as soon as discriminatory. It ranged from misleading the jury about evidence that did not exist to striking prospective jurors based on race. A jailhouse informant who claimed Flowers had confessed to him recanted in recorded telephone conversations with American Public Media's "In the Dark" podcast. The protection attorneys said the Mississippi Supreme Court docket failed to well apply U.S. Supreme Court docket precedent in determining whether folk occupy been unconstitutionally kept off a jury on the foundation of bustle.

Related News:

  • How Meghan Markle Plans to Celebrate Her 38th Birthday

    How Meghan Markle Plans to Celebrate Her 38th Birthday

    The artsy shot however, has been criticised by online trolls who demand to see more of Archie than just glimpses of his face. Prince Harry and Meghan Markle's son will soon be baptised at the same church where his parents were married.
    United States of America  vs. Chile in 2019 FIFA Women's World Cup

    United States of America vs. Chile in 2019 FIFA Women's World Cup

    Japan, playing in Group D with England, also went through to the knockout stage because both the United States and Sweden won. Carli Lloyd is the first player to score in six consecutive Women's World Cup games, netting nine goals in those matches.
    Stanley Cup Game 7 Dominates

    Stanley Cup Game 7 Dominates

    But by the end of the playoffs, he ended up being one of the team's top shutdown defencemen, logging more than 23 minutes a night. Even Bruins coach Bruce Cassidy conceded that the Blues "play a different game" when they're ahead.
  • Argentina Isn’t Ruling Out a Cyberattack in Major Power Outage

    Argentina Isn’t Ruling Out a Cyberattack in Major Power Outage

    Since taking office, Macri has said that gradual austerity measures were needed to revive the country's struggling economy. Tierra del Fuego in the far south is the only area that remains unaffected because it is not connected to the power grid.
    Sarri Juventus deal done - media - English

    Sarri Juventus deal done - media - English

    Sarri succeeded Antonio Conte as Chelsea manager last summer after spending three years at Napoli. Sarri's exit should be finalised this weekend after Juventus agreed to pay up to £8m compensation.
    The people of Central Asia smoke marijuana during rituals 2,500 years ago

    The people of Central Asia smoke marijuana during rituals 2,500 years ago

    If cannabis smoking originated there, or nearby, it may have helped to spread cannabis smoking from Central Asia around the world. Still, he points out that the research expands the range of sites linked with early cannabis use.
  • The Truth About Prince William's Relationship With Prince Harry

    The Truth About Prince William's Relationship With Prince Harry

    Meanwhile, then-Hollywood actress Meghan met Harry much later when she was 35 in 2016. It comes just days after Meghan and Harry split from William's charity .
    Airbus demands chance to bid for IAG’s surprise Boeing narrow-body order

    Airbus demands chance to bid for IAG’s surprise Boeing narrow-body order

    The European manufacturer unveiled the A321XLR, a long-haul version of the A321neo that competes with Boeing's grounded 737 Max . Of the 50 planes, 38 are new orders and 12 are conversions to the new model from previous orders for A320neo jets.
    Facebook to pay users who allow access to phone data

    Facebook to pay users who allow access to phone data

    Soon, you can earn while you browse, provided you are willing to share your internet browsing history and app data with Facebook. The app will be used to help the company conduct market research and all participants will be paid.
  • Messi salvages point for Argentina as they keep Copa America hopes alive

    Messi salvages point for Argentina as they keep Copa America hopes alive

    Argentina have a very important game coming up against Paraguay in the Copa America 2019 as they are now 4th in Group B . Messi was the goalscorer for his country after Paraguay had taken the lead through Richard Sanchez .
    Shakur Stevenson on Fury's Vegas Win, Opponent Fallout

    Shakur Stevenson on Fury's Vegas Win, Opponent Fallout

    After his knockdown in the second, Schwarz's corner was ready to stop the fight at the same time the referee stopped it. Fury went on to win the bout in the second round after landing a flurry of powerful blows on the German.
    Warner hits century as Australia beat Pakistan

    Warner hits century as Australia beat Pakistan

    Sarfaraz added a rapid collapse that saw three wickets lost for 11 runs as Pakistan slumped to 147-5 had also proved costly. It's simple - if Pakistan want to stay in the tournament, they have to bring an "A plus" performance and win that game.

Most liked

The United States and Iran: A Step Closer to Open Conflict?
Monday's troop increase announcement comes on top of 1,500 extra announced by President Donald Trump last month. European powers have warned Iran they will have no choice but to reimpose sanctions if the deal is violated.

New York Knicks: 3 reasons R.J. Barrett was a good pick
Atlanta is also sending a heavily protected Cleveland first-round pick in 2020 to the Pelicans, sources said. The Los Angeles Lakers entered Thursday's draft with a roster in desperate need of cheap labor but no picks.

Ocasio-Cortez doubles down on concentration camp comments
The controversial comments were ill received by many, with critics saying evoking the Holocaust was not an appropriate comparison. It is the conclusion of expert analysis".

Turkey urges adherence to United Nations report's recommendations on Khashoggi murder
The report is the most complete look at what really happened to Khashoggi that has been made public, reported The NYT. The (UN) report reiterates what has already been published and circulated in the media.

Dominican Republic deaths: Federal Bureau of Investigation close to identifying cause of mystery Caribbean deaths
The autopsy cited heart attack, respiratory failure, and a fluid accumulation in her lungs as the cause of death. According to his niece Chloe Arnold, who spoke with Fox News , a minibar scotch could be the culprit.

Ninth U.S. Tourist Dies Mysteriously in Dominican Republic
Joseph Allen , 55, also died this month, and his friends told the family that he complained about not feeling well last Wednesday. InsureMyTrip says search queries about travel insurance for Dominican Republic vacations are up 600 percent versus a year ago.

Darius Garland in ‘serious consideration’ at No. 3 overall
He played just five total college games due to a meniscus injury, and he wasn't exactly at a high-profile school in Vanderbilt. There has been some rumblings about Vanderbilt point guard Darius Garland in recent days, but that is likely just noise.

Facebook to 'print even more money' with Libra cryptocurrency, Citi says
Calibra also won't share account or financial information for Facebook, aside from limited cases. Earlier this year, United Kingdom lawmakers said the company behaved like "digital gangsters".

PM May would not repeat criticism of London Mayor - spokesman
The US President's latest intervention on Twitter follows in the same vein, demanding that Khan should be replaced. Trump tweeted: " LONDON needs a new mayor ASAP".

Gloria Vanderbilt, iconic designer and artist, dies at age 95
Vanderbilt went on to became an actress, painter, model and acclaimed fashion designer of hip-hugging jeans in the 1970s. Vanderbilt passed away Monday morning from stomach cancer, according to a report published by The Hollywood Reporter .

Raptors, fans take to Toronto streets to celebrate National Basketball Association championship
Enthusiastic fans festooned the streets of Toronto in Raptors colors - red, purple, black and white. His press secretary said Ford wants the day to be about the fans and players, not politicians.

Stanley Cup game seven delivers highest National Hockey League ratings on record
The Blues then knocked off the Jets, Stars, and Sharks to reach the Stanley Cup Final for the first time since 1970. As she improved, so did the Blues, surprisingly skating into the playoffs with Laila as an inspiration.

Google Photos stops syncing with Google Drive in July
Google Drive and Photos will not automatically sync photos and videos starting July 10, according to a blog post Wednesday. Google has just announced important changes to automatic sync between Google Drive and Google Photos .

Andy Ruiz Jr. wants $50 million to rematch Anthony Joshua in UK
For now at least we know exactly what Fury thinks about his rival and it's refreshingly honest and respectful. Tyson Fury claims fellow heavyweight and former world champion Anthony Joshua is "finished" in boxing.

Trump defends tariff threat against Mexico, calls it 'beautiful thing'
It also wants curbs on subsidies for Chinese state-owned enterprises and better access for USA firms in Chinese markets. The telephone interview was unusual because it appeared to be in response to an earlier CNBC segment, in which a U.S.

Most Commented